310S and 304H are routinely substituted for each other on a purchase order, and the substitution is usually wrong. Both are austenitic stainless steels, both are used in furnaces and heat exchangers, and both are described as high temperature grades, yet they solve two different problems: 310S solves oxidation, and 304H solves creep strength. Choosing between them starts with knowing which of those two problems the application actually has.
The Composition Difference That Drives Everything
304H is an 18/8 steel with elevated carbon. 310S is a 25/20 steel with carbon deliberately held low. That single contrast explains almost every behavioural difference downstream.
| Element | 304H (UNS S30409) | 310S (UNS S31008) |
| Chromium | 18.0 - 20.0 | 24.0 - 26.0 |
| Nickel | 8.0 - 11.0 | 19.0 - 22.0 |
| Carbon | 0.04 - 0.10 | 0.08 max |
| Silicon | 0.75 max | 1.50 max |
| Yield min (MPa) | 205 | 205 |
| Tensile min (MPa) | 515 | 515 |
The carbon range in 304H is not an accident of chemistry. Between roughly 0.04 and 0.10 percent, the carbon precipitates as fine carbides during service in the 500 to 650 degrees C window, and those carbides pin the grain boundaries against creep. That is what makes 304H a high temperature grade rather than a stronger room temperature grade.
310S takes the opposite approach. Its carbon is capped at 0.08 percent because carbon hurts weldability and toughness at the very high temperatures the grade is designed for, and the 25 percent chromium does the high temperature work instead by building a dense, adherent oxide scale.
Oxidation Resistance: 310S Wins Clearly
In clean, dry air the practical continuous service ceiling of 310S is around 1150 degrees C, with intermittent service usually quoted at about 1035 degrees C because thermal cycling spalls the scale. For 304 and 304H the corresponding figures are far lower, roughly 870 degrees C continuous and 925 degrees C intermittent in the same clean-air condition.
Above about 900 degrees C, 304H forms a chromium-rich scale that still protects, but the scale is thin and breaks down under thermal cycling. 310S holds its scale to a considerably higher temperature because the higher chromium and nickel content stabilise it. In a furnace with a daily heat cycle, the difference shows up as scale spalling and wall loss on 304H long before it shows on 310S.
Creep Strength: 304H Wins in the 500-650 Degrees C Band
The counterintuitive part is that 310S, despite being the more expensive alloy, is not automatically the stronger one in the temperature band where most heat exchangers actually operate. Between about 500 and 650 degrees C, 304H's carbide precipitation gives it a creep rupture advantage that 310S does not have, because 310S deliberately has too little carbon to form those carbides and relies on solid solution strengthening instead.
This is why 304H appears in superheater tubing, steam headers and reformer outlet lines where the metal temperature sits in that band, while 310S appears in furnace internals, radiant sections, muffles and supports where the metal temperature is closer to 1000 degrees C and oxidation rather than creep is the governing damage mechanism.
Generalising the two grades as 310S is the high temperature one and 304H is the cheap one misses the mechanism entirely. At 600 degrees C the creep question favours 304H; at 1000 degrees C the oxidation question favours 310S; and at neither temperature is the other grade automatically acceptable.
How Thermal Expansion Changes the Design
The two grades also differ in how much they grow when heated, and on a long straight run that difference becomes a mechanical problem rather than a metallurgical one.
| Property | 304H | 310S |
| Coefficient of expansion (20-100 C) | about 17.5 x 10-6 /K | about 18.5 x 10-6 /K |
| Thermal conductivity at 20 C (W/m.K) | about 16 | about 15 |
| Magnetic in annealed condition | no | no |
The expansion gap is not large in percentage terms, but over a 12 metre run at 800 degrees C it translates into several millimetres of differential movement that the support and anchor design has to absorb. A substitution made late in the project, after the expansion loops are already detailed, is a change order rather than a material swap.
Welding and Fabrication Differences
Both grades weld with matching austenitic filler, but the shop has to treat them differently:
- 310S is more sensitive to sigma phase formation when held in the 600 to 900 degrees C range, so prolonged post-weld heat treatment is avoided rather than prescribed. Solution annealing, if required, is done at a higher temperature and followed by rapid cooling.
- 304H's higher carbon makes it slightly more prone to sensitisation at the weld heat affected zone if it is held too long in the 450 to 850 degrees C band. On thin wall tube this matters more than on heavy plate.
- Both grades need low heat input and interpass temperature control, but 310S tolerates slightly higher heat input because its higher nickel content keeps the austenite stable.
- Neither grade is normally stress relieved after welding. If a client specification asks for it, the temperature has to be chosen carefully or the treatment does more harm than the residual stress.
The Selection Rules That Actually Work
Four questions settle most of these decisions before any calculation:
- What is the metal temperature, not the process temperature? A 900 degrees C process with good insulation may put the metal at 650 degrees C, which changes the answer completely.
- Is the environment oxidising, and does it cycle? Continuous clean-air duty and daily thermal cycling give very different life predictions even at the same peak temperature.
- Is the governing damage mechanism creep or oxidation? If the client cannot answer this, the grade selection is being made on price alone.
- Is there a code constraint? ASME section II part D lists the allowable stress by grade and temperature, and for 304H it is given to a considerably higher temperature than many buyers expect.
Where Each Grade Is the Wrong Choice
304H is the wrong choice for furnace internals that see 1000 degrees C in cyclic service, for calibration fixtures, and for any application where the atmosphere contains sulphur or vanadium, because the lower chromium and nickel content cannot build a protective scale under those conditions. 310S is the wrong choice for superheater tubing in the 600 degrees C band where creep rather than oxidation governs, and for welded heavy sections that would have to sit in the sigma forming range during fabrication.
There is also a cost dimension worth stating plainly: 310S carries roughly 20 percent nickel and 25 percent chromium, so it prices well above 304H. Using it as a default upgrade on a 600 degrees C application pays for alloy the mechanism does not need, while the creep performance is actually worse than the cheaper grade.
A Practical Comparison Table for Procurement
When a drawing says high temperature stainless without naming a grade, this table is usually enough to open the conversation with the end user:
| Application | Governing mechanism | Usual choice |
| Furnace radiant internals, muffle, retort | Oxidation at 950-1150 C | 310S |
| Superheater and reheater tubing | Creep at 550-650 C | 304H |
| Heat exchanger tubes, process side | Creep plus moderate corrosion | 304H or 316H |
| Annealing fixtures, trays, skid rails | Oxidation plus thermal cycling | 310S |
| Flue gas ducting, lower temperature | Corrosion plus moderate heat | 304H or 316 |
| Sulphur-bearing furnace atmosphere | Sulphidation | Neither; use a nickel alloy |
What to Put on the Purchase Order
A specification that names only the grade leaves the mill free to supply the cheapest condition that meets the chemistry. To close that gap, the order should state:
- The UNS number, S30409 or S31008, not just the common name.
- The product form and the dimensional standard, for example ASTM A213 for tube or A240 for plate.
- The heat treatment condition, solution annealed, and whether a hardness check is required.
- The grain size for 304H tube if creep life matters, since coarse grain improves creep resistance.
- The test and document requirements, including EN 10204 3.1 certificates and any intergranular corrosion test.
Related stock on this site: 310S stainless steel pipe, 310S stainless steel plate and contact us for a grade review against the actual metal temperature.





