In harsh industrial environments, 347H and 317L stainless steels represent two distinct performance directions. 347H, with its core niobium stabilization treatment, focuses on high-temperature strength and creep resistance. 317L, on the other hand, boasts superior resistance to chloride pitting and crevice corrosion due to its high molybdenum content.
HT PIPE is a leading stockist and global exporter with over 15 years of expertise in international trade. We supply pipes, plates, round bars, and a comprehensive range of pipe fittings, flanges, and valves. Contact us now for free quotes and personalized product information.
Chemical composition difference between ss347h and ss317l material
347H, through the addition of niobium (Nb) as a stabilizing element, effectively inhibits the precipitation of chromium carbide between grains, thus providing excellent resistance to intergranular corrosion, crucial for welded components and equipment used in sensitive media. Its high-temperature strength and creep resistance are also superior to ordinary austenitic stainless steels (such as 304). 347H stainless steel exhibits good low-temperature toughness in the annealed state and is non-magnetic.
The core advantage of 317L lies in its high molybdenum (Mo) content (typically exceeding 3%). Molybdenum significantly enhances the material's resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion in chloride environments and other reducing media. Meanwhile, its low carbon (L) content ensures that the material is insensitive to sensitization caused by carbide precipitation during welding and hot working, thus maintaining good corrosion resistance.
347h and 317l Corrosion Resistance and High-Temperature Performance
Selection in Corrosive Environments
347H: Resists well against corrosion from various acids, alkalis, and salt solutions, and exhibits good oxidation resistance in air below 800℃.
317L: In environments containing chlorides (such as seawater, brine, and certain chemical processes), its resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion is generally superior to 347H. It also resists corrosion from sulfuric acid, acidic chlorine, and phosphoric acid.
Selection at High Temperatures
347H: Due to its higher carbon content and the stabilizing effect of niobium, 347H exhibits higher strength and better creep resistance at high temperatures. When the operating temperature is consistently above 500℃, especially above 600℃, 347H is usually the more suitable choice.
317L: While 317L also exhibits good high-temperature performance, its main advantage lies not in long-term high-temperature strength. It's important to note that in the sensitive temperature range of 800°F – 1500°F (approximately 427°C – 816°C), the low-carbon 317L offers better resistance to intergranular corrosion caused by carbide precipitation.
Welding and Machining
347H: Offers good weldability. For welding, ER347 or ER347H welding wire is generally recommended to achieve matched weld performance.
317L: Its low-carbon design results in excellent weldability, and post-weld corrosion resistance is less prone to degradation due to sensitization. ER317L welding wire is typically used for welding.
How to choose ss347h and ss317l?
Chloride Concern
If the equipment is exposed to chlorides, the material's resistance to pitting corrosion and stress corrosion cracking must be carefully evaluated. In this case, 317L, due to its higher molybdenum content, typically offers more reliable corrosion resistance.
High Temperature and Creep Stress Assessment
For equipment requiring long-term operation at high temperatures (e.g., above 500°C) and under certain stress, 347H is more advantageous due to its superior high-temperature strength and creep resistance.
Manufacturing Process Considerations
When components have complex structures, require extensive welding, and cannot undergo post-weld solution annealing:
- 347H, through niobium stabilization, possesses inherent resistance to intergranular corrosion.
- 317L, on the other hand, relies on its low-carbon properties to prevent sensitization in welded areas.
Both provide protection, but their mechanisms of action differ.
Cost and Market Availability
Generally, due to its higher alloy content (especially molybdenum), 317L may cost more than 347H. However, the final cost and supply stability need to be analyzed comprehensively in conjunction with the specific market supply and demand situation.
Technical FAQ
Q1: Can 317L be used in high-temperature applications instead of 347H?
A1: No. 317L is a low-carbon grade (max 0.03% C) specifically designed to limit sensitization in wet corrosive services. At high temperatures (above 425°C), low-carbon grades lack the necessary creep-rupture strength required by ASME codes. 347H features higher carbon combined with niobium stabilization, specifically tailored for sustained high-temperature load bearing.
Q2: Why does 317L provide better pitting resistance than 347H?
A2: Pitting resistance is directly related to an alloy's chemical profile, calculated by the Pitting Resistance Equivalent Number. 317L contains 3.0% to 4.0% Molybdenum, whereas 347H does not have intentional molybdenum additions. This gives 317L a significantly higher PREN, making it far superior at resisting chloride-induced pitting.
Q3: What international standards apply to 347H and 317L pipe fittings and flanges?
A3: Forged components like flanges and valves are governed by ASTM A182 / ASME SA182. Wrought factory-made butt-weld piping fittings (such as elbows and tees) are covered under ASTM A403 / ASME SA403. Pipes are standardly specified to ASTM A312 / ASME SA312.
Contact now
